Sandbars managed for least terns within the Missouri River: evaluating the influence of fish, spatial scale and environment on habitat use
2012-09
Loading...
View/Download File
Persistent link to this item
Statistics
View StatisticsJournal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Title
Sandbars managed for least terns within the Missouri River: evaluating the influence of fish, spatial scale and environment on habitat use
Authors
Published Date
2012-09
Publisher
Type
Thesis or Dissertation
Abstract
Interior Least Terns (Sternula antillarum) nest on barren sandy habitats,
typically sandbars and shorelines within large river systems of the central United
States. Loss of natural ecosystem processes which create and maintain these habitats
is considered the primary reason for population decline and Federal listing of this
population. Throughout their range, management for Least Terns focuses on
maintenance of breeding habitats, including placement of dredged material
specifically as nesting substrate. Wide expanses of barren land are known to attract
Least Terns, yet specific small scale habitat features are thought to trigger nest habitat
selection. Yet as a plunge-diving piscivore, Least Terns also rely on ready access to
appropriately sized slender-bodied fish: <52 mm total length for adults and <34 mm
total length for young chicks. It remains unknown whether sandbar construction is a
benefit or a detriment to forage abundance for Least Terns. Lastly, the relationship
between availability of nesting habitats and required foraging habitats remains
ambiguous. This information is needed to refine understanding of Least Tern habitat
needs from a foraging ecology perspective, and contribute to knowledge and potential
value of habitat restoration efforts. This study evaluates 1) the shallow water (<1.5
m) fish community near river and mechanically created emergent sandbars during
three nesting seasons (2006-2008), 2) nest-scale habitat selection to determine if nest
habitats differ between constructed and natural sandbars, and it evaluates the
consequences of this selection on nest success, and 3) the potential associations
between specific habitat features, at differing spatial scales, associated with airborne and foraging Least Terns. The research effort focused on the 95 kilometers of Gavins
Point Reach of the Missouri River, between Yankton, SD and Ponca, NE during the
Least Tern nesting season in 2006-2008. We sampled fish within 15-16 areas every
two weeks from late May - July to document the relative abundance, species richness,
and size classes of fish. Using systematic surveys on sandbars every 2-3 days, we
detected and tracked 869 Least Tern nests until eggs hatched or failed, on constructed and natural sandbars in the Missouri River examining them for evidence of
microhabitat selection at the nest and 3 m from nest. Least Terns successful foraging
sites (N=416) were compared to a paired nearby random location to evaluate evidence
of habitat selection during successful foraging in 2007-2008. We used systematic
surveys every two weeks from late May - July in each year to identify Least Tern
airborne (foraging or flying) locations within the river corridor (2006:966 sites,
2007:2940 sites, 2008:2003 sites), recording them using spot mapping. We modeled
the probability that an observation (random and bird) as an airborne tern using
logistic regression and habitat variables derived from remote sensing. Lastly, to
refine our understanding of behavior in specifying habitat use, we modeled the
probability of a location as a foraging site.
Fish relative abundance was negatively related to depth. Catches were
dominated by schooling species, including emerald shiner, sand shiner, spotfin shiner,
and bigmouth buffalo. Significant inter-annual differences in relative abundance
were observed, with generally increasing trends in intra-seasonal relative abundance
of shiners and the smallest size classes of fish (<34 mm). Significant differences in
the fish communities between the sandbar types were not detected in this study.
These results suggest that mechanical sandbar habitats host comparable fish communities at similar levels of relative abundance. Among nests, significant differences were observed in substrates, amount of
debris, and measures of vegetation between natural and created habitats, and between
microhabitat at nests and the surrounding area. In general, Least Tern nest sites had
coarser and larger substrate materials at the nest, more debris, and shorter and less
vegetation compared to areas within the 3 m surrounding area. Nests in constructed
habitats had a greater proportion of coarse substrates and less vegetation or debris
than naturally created habitats. Observed nest success among constructed sandbars
was 1.8x greater than that recorded among nests on natural sandbars, but a greater
proportion of nests on natural bars were in or adjoining moist habitats where they
were frequently destroyed. The best supported model predicting nest success on constructed and natural sandbars each included positive associations with percentage
of pebble substrate, but inclusion of additional habitat predictors differed by sandbar
type. Selection of microhabitat characteristics at the nest and vicinity constrains this
species to barren water and wind scoured habitats. Historically, scoured habitats and
the comparative abundance of debris within sites may have been a cue indicating safe
habitats as river stage decreased. Water management regimes during this study
favored survival of nests on higher elevation sandbars which included limited areas of
wet substrates, typical of mechanically constructed sandbars.
Among the micro-site habitat assessments for foraging birds, differences were
not observed in water depth availability between natural or mechanically created
habitats. Based on AIC relative importance scores, the variables water depth and
microhabitat characteristics were most critical among micro-site characteristics of
successful foraging locations; turbidity and larger scale aquatic features were
comparatively of less importance. Within the greater landscape, Least Tern airborne
locations within the river corridor were best explained by multi-scale logistic regressions; birds concentrated in areas with higher proportions of sandbar and wet
sand habitats (200 m radius), while avoiding trees (50 m radius). When applied to a
reserved sample of random locations, results suggest that in any given year, 40-97%
of river corridor habitats were likely unsuitable for airborne terns. Furthermore,
habitat use differed by behavior; foraging birds approached nearer to wet sand
patches and in areas with less emergent sandbar habitat than flying birds, with some
habitat relationships differing by year. Despite the surficial visual uniformity of
many aquatic habitats on the Missouri River, successful foraging by Least Terns was
associated with shallow, slack-water microhabitats adjacent to emergent sandbars and
within areas with a greater proportion of sandbar habitat. This study demonstrates the
importance of incorporating both spatial scale and behavior into ecological
assessments of Least Tern foraging habitats.
Description
University of Minnesota Ph.D. dissertation 2012. Major: Conservation Biology. Advisor: Francesca J. Cuthbert. 1 computer file (PDF); xv, 177 pages.
Related to
Replaces
License
Collections
Series/Report Number
Funding information
Isbn identifier
Doi identifier
Previously Published Citation
Suggested citation
Stucker, Jennifer Hathaway. (2012). Sandbars managed for least terns within the Missouri River: evaluating the influence of fish, spatial scale and environment on habitat use. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/143760.
Content distributed via the University Digital Conservancy may be subject to additional license and use restrictions applied by the depositor. By using these files, users agree to the Terms of Use. Materials in the UDC may contain content that is disturbing and/or harmful. For more information, please see our statement on harmful content in digital repositories.