Browsing by Subject "schooling"

Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Bordering State and Society: Community Schools in Zambia
    (2019-08) Bamattre, Richard
    Amidst an international push for education for all, people in Zambia began building their own schools most notably in the 1990s. These so-called community schools make up a significant portion of the country's primary school system and potentially represent fundamental changes in the border between state and society in providing education. In this dissertation, I question: why community schools exist in Zambia and continue to operate; how they have been rationalized by the state and public; what learning outcomes result from a bordering between government and community schools. Using a mixed methods framework grounded in critical realism, I analyzed policies, interviews, public opinion surveys, and literacy and numeracy assessment data. I found that community schools existed prior to the 1990s, but in a politically different way. After 1991, these schools grew organically nationwide, amidst an economic crisis, structural adjustment policies, and an unprecedented drop in education financing. In the following decades, the Zambian state promoted different borderings between itself and society, from promoting an explicit neoliberal view of parental responsibility in education to supervising a parallel system of state and community schools. While I find evidence that state and community schools serve similar populations, students who attend community schools have significantly lower learning outcomes even after controlling for factors that should explain the difference. At the same time, there are additional inequities in this parallel system related to the location of schools and the household socio-economic status of students. Findings are significant for both theory and practice: among other implications, this study points to the opportunities for mixed methods research in education, and highlights how conceptions of state and society in schooling – whether made explicit or not – can have political and practical consequences.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Community Participation in Community Day Secondary Schooling for Orphaned and Vulnerable Students in Malawi in an Era of Shrinking Community
    (2017-09) Kaunda, Zikani
    ABSTRACT The purpose of this dissertation is to interrogate the meanings of “community” “participation,” and “community participation” concepts that are central to international development and national policy discourses in Malawi concerning Community Day Secondary Schools (CDSS) and the support for orphaned and vulnerable students’ (OVSs) schooling. The dissertation examines how community participation in OVS’s schooling is understood by various stakeholders, and how it is understood in relation to CDSSs in particular. It also explores, from various stakeholders’ views, whether and how community participation should play a role in supporting the schooling of OVSs, and how various interpretations of community participation may or may not enable OVSs to access and persist in secondary school. The study also contrasts and compares various international development frameworks for understanding the meaning of and debates about community participation and its impact on marginalized children. This research utilizes critical and interpretivist theoretical frameworks and qualitative methods of inquiry to understand how community participation is experienced across communities and organizational scale (community, school, district, national, and international). The study is designed as a multi-sited comparative case study, in which I ground my interrogation of existing perceptions and meanings of the concepts and institutionalized relations of power related to community participation in the secondary education of OVSs in two CDSSs in the northern and southern regions of Malawi. This allowed me to critically examine international and national discourses of community participation and how they engage (or fail to engage) with diverse stakeholders’ lived experiences and practices at the school and community level.