Browsing by Subject "Social identity theory"

Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Identity relativity: linking stereotype threat and social comparison as parallel processes.
    (2009-09) Russ, Suzanne L.
    Academic achievement gaps across racial, socioeconomic, and gender groups have persisted in the United States despite formidable recent attention on reducing the disparities. While a wide range of social, personal, and cultural factors contribute to the disparities, the simple knowledge that one belongs to a poorly-performing, stereotyped group can impair performance for even very successful members of stereotyped groups. This phenomenon is known as stereotype threat, and has been documented extensively over more than a decade of research. This study sought to elucidate the underpinnings of stereotype threat through the lens of identity relativity, suggesting that dissonance between and among identities contribute to performance deficits under different levels of identity activation. The hypothesis that stereotype threat is a type of social comparison operating under collective rather than individual identity activation was tested: an experiment was conducted in which test performance and three levels of self-esteem (implicit, explicit, and collective) served as dependent measures after activation of either an intergroup or interpersonal comparison. Subjects included community college students, about whom mild stereotypes are shown to exist. While some predictions were supported, the overall pattern of results did not support the hypotheses. Discussion builds that case that the hypotheses were valid but the methods used to investigate the phenomenon were flawed. Recommendations for redesigning the study are proposed. If the connection between stereotype threat and social comparison can be established, then research in both areas can be used to minimize detrimental comparisons and narrow the gap associated with pervasive negative stereotypes.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Social identity in close relationships
    (2014-09) Filson, Jennifer Moses
    A series of three studies examined the role that social identity plays in close romantic relationships. Specifically, the concept that those in romantic relationships can and do develop a unique romantic-relationship identity with their partners is examined. The first study establishes that existing indices of group identification can be altered to assess relationship identification. Using correlations, factor analysis, and group differences between those in committed romantic relationships and those who are actively dating, Study 1 confirms the existence of romantic-relationship identity and the construct validity of the measures intended to assess this construct. Study 2 uses research findings grounded in social identity theory about how people respond to intragroup versus intergroup threats to social identity to determine whether those in close relationships respond to threats to relationship identity as they do to threats to other social identities. Study 2 determines that, in the context of romantic relationships, men generally respond to intergroup threats as social identity theory would predict, whereas women do not. Study 3 was an attempt to extend the intergroup findings for men to women. Study 3 confirms that both men and women generally respond with increased relationship identification when their partners are criticized on an important dimension, such as intelligence. The possible moderating roles of adult romantic attachment and self-esteem are explored. Finally, implications for theory and research are discussed.