Browsing by Author "Huber, Christopher"
Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
Results Per Page
Sort Options
Item Faking and the Validity of Personality Tests: Using New Faking-Resistant Measures to Study Some Old Questions(2017-02) Huber, ChristopherDespite strong evidence supporting the validity of personality measures for personnel selection, their susceptibility to faking has been a persistent concern. Research has found that many job applicants exaggerate their possession of desirable traits, and there are reasons to believe that this distortion reduces criterion-related validity. However, the lack of studies that combine experimental control with real-world generalizability makes it difficult to isolate the effects of applicant faking. Experimental studies have typically induced faking using explicit instructions to fake, which elicit unusually extreme faking compared to typical applicant settings. A variety of non-experimental approaches have also been employed, but these approaches are largely inadequate for establishing cause-and-effect relationships. Thus, researchers continue to debate whether applicant faking substantially attenuates the validity of personality tests. The present study used a new experimental framework to study this question and related methodological issues in the faking literature. First, it included a subtle incentive to fake in addition to explicit instructions to respond honestly or fake good. Second, it compared faking on standard Likert scales to faking on multidimensional forced choice (MFC) scales designed to resist deception. Third, it compared more and less fakable versions of the same MFC inventory to eliminate confounding differences between MFC and Likert scales. The result was a 3 x 3 design that simultaneously manipulated the motivation and ability to fake, allowing for a more rigorous examination of the faking–validity relationship. Results indicated complex relationships between faking and the validity of personality scores. Directed fakers were much better at raising their scores on Likert scales than MFC measures of the same traits. However, MFC scales failed to retain more validity than Likert scales when participants faked. Supplemental analyses suggested that extreme faking decimated the construct validity of all scales regardless of their fakability. Faking also added new common method variance to the Likert scales, which in turn contributed to the scales’ criterion-related validity. In addition to the effects of faking, the present study investigated two recurring methodological issues in the faking literature. First, I investigated the claim that directed faking is fundamentally different from typical faking by comparing results from directed and incentivized fakers. Directed faking results generally replicated using a subtle incentive to fake, but the effects were much smaller and less consistent. Second, some have argued that traditional criterion-related validity coefficients fail to capture the negative effects of faking on actual selection decisions. I investigated this possibility by creating simulated selection pools in which fakers and honest responders competed for limited positions. The simulation results generally indicated reasonable correspondence between validity estimates and selected group performance, suggesting that validity coefficients adequately reflected the effects of faking. Results are interpreted using existing theories of faking, and new methodologies are proposed to advance the study of typical faking behavior.Item Studying Si-H Mode Sensitivity to Internal and External Perturbations through Vibrational Spectroscopy(2015-08) Huber, ChristopherOver the course of this thesis, I hope to display an understanding of how a vibrational mode's sensitivity is dictated by inter- and intramolecular structure and composition. In the following chapters, a new vibrational ultrafast spectroscopic probe was used to study solvatochromism, confined solvent structure and dynamics, and structural dynamics of solid state materials, subsequently gaining knowledge of the probe’s inherent sensitivity and limitations in the process. First Chapter 2 provides a comprehensive background on 2D-IR spectroscopy, including the theory behind the technique and subsequent data analysis. Chapter 3 presents a solvatochromic study on a carbonyl vibration highlighting the analyses that will be used to extract molecular information from FTIR measurements of the same mode in different solvents. Chapter 4 utilizes some of the analyses from Chapter 3 to characterize a new Si-H probe intrinsically bound in a nanoporous silica sol-gel solid state sample. Chapter 4 also provides an introductory description of this novel mode’s sensitivity to solvent through solvatochromic analyses and ultrafast spectroscopy. Chapter 5 investigates a surface bound Si-H probe’s ability to measure interfacial solvent structure and dynamics inside mesoporous silica nanoparticles. Finally, Chapter 6 is a comprehensive study of the sensitivity of an Si-H mode to the structural and compositional evolution during a silica sol-gel formation and subsequent aging.