DSpace DSpace

University of Minnesota Digital Conservancy >
University of Minnesota - Twin Cities >
Minnesota Journal of Law, Science & Technology >
Volume 14, Issue 1 (Winter 2013) >

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/11299/144227

Title: Developing a Durable Right to Health Care
Authors: Fuse Brown, Erin C.
Keywords: Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
ACA
right to health care
healthcare policy
healthcare legislation
healthcare law
durable rights
superstatute
health insurance
private health insurance
health insurance market
healthcare economics
health insurance economics
Affordable Care Act
Issue Date: 12-Feb-2013
Abstract: The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) signature accomplishment was the creation of a statutory right to health care for the uninsured. This is a momentous change in policy, addressing one of the most vexing social issues of our time and affecting millions of people and billions of dollars of the U.S. economy. This ambition and the degree of societal and political debate leading up to the Act’s passage suggests that it is a “superstatute,” a rare breed of statute that can, among other things, create rights and institutions more typically thought to be the province of constitutional undertaking. Nevertheless, the structure of the ACA’s right to health care makes it fragile and reduces its chances of becoming a durable right. The ACA may end up as a “quasi-superstatute:” a statute that aspires but fails to become a superstatute through a failure of political and public entrenchment. The problem is that the right to health care is to be delivered largely through changes to the private health insurance market, requiring the collective action of many reluctant actors, including unwilling states and recalcitrant individuals. Even though it survived legal challenge before the Supreme Court, the ACA’s right to health care faces significant political and market challenges that threaten to retrench rather than entrench its benefits in the public’s mind. The vulnerability of this right to health care is concentrated early in its lifespan, and if it survives these early years, forces such as the endowment effect may strengthen the right’s durability as its benefits take hold. The fragility of the ACA’s right to health care and its uncertain path to durability provide lessons to future framers of a right to health care regarding the long timeframe for implementation, uncertainty, complexity, and structure. The risk of becoming a “quasi-superstatute” highlights the importance of how such social reforms ought to be structured to achieve entrenchment and durability after the ink is dry on the new legislation.
URI: http://purl.umn.edu/144227
Appears in Collections:Volume 14, Issue 1 (Winter 2013)

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
Durable-Right-to-Healthcare-by-Erin-Fuse-Brown-MN-Journal-Law-Science-Tech-Issue-14-1.pdf329.06 kBPDFView/Open

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.